SUE ANN'S BAKERY Online Ordering Menu

817 E NEW HAVEN AVE
MELBOURNE, FL 32901

10:00 AM - 4:00 PM

95% of 22 customers recommended

Curbside Pickup Available

Start your carryout order.

Check Availability

Menu Icon Legend

Cookies

Gluten Free Cookies

Gluten free cookies have bittersweet chocolate, tart cherries, coconut and toasted walnuts. Vegan cookies are salted chocolate chip.

Pumpkin Cookies

Cut Out Cookies With Sugar Sprinkles

Cream cheese dough makes this a soft tasty treat with sugar sprinkles, choose your favorite shape.

Cupcake

Carrot is a fan favorite!

Pineapple Passionfruit Cupcake-SEASONAL

Lemon Raspberry Cupcake

Our most popular wedding cake flavor turned into a cupcake, lemon cake with raspberry filling topped with lemon buttercream.

Gluten Free Cupcake

The choices change daily! Could be vanilla with strawberry filling or a yummy chocolate or even carrot!

Cake scrap Cups

Coconut Cream Pie Cupcake

Bars & Brownies

Pumpkin Cheesecake Squares

Red Velvet Irish Cream Brownie

An apple pie in a bite, shortbread crust, soft apples, crumb topping with a drizzle of sweetness to finish it off.

Buttery shortbread crust with mounds of blueberries and a crumbly top.

Brookie Brownie

Decadent chocolate brownie with a creamy cappuccino frosting and a sprinkle of chocolate and coffee on top.

Chocolate Raspberry Bar

Buttery shortbread crust, a layer of chocolate fudge base topped with raspberry and crumbs...

For coconut lovers, a buttery shortbread crust with a coconut filling, topped with more coconut...all about coconut!

Such a fan favorite, a delicate shortbread crust with lemon filling baked just right.

Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake Bar

What to do with all the blueberries we picked! Make a cheesecake bar with it, lemon cheesecake base with so many blueberries added.

Lemon Cherry Cheesecake Bar

Lemon cheesecake with cherries added for a pop of flavor!

Mint Brownie Bar

Chocolate and mint go together so perfectly, mint patties fill this brownie and mint added to the chocolate tops this brownie...

Mystery Bar Box-ASSORTED BARS

A selection of our bars, cut into quarters for a taste of different brownie and dessert bars.

Peanut Butter Truffle Bar

Chocolate brownie base with a decadent peanut butter mousse topped with chocolate ganache

Pina colada Bar

Buttery Shortbread crust with pineapple and coconut and a touch of rum make up this island bar

Raspberry Almond Bar

Buttery almond shortbread crust with raspberry filling and buttery almond crumbs on top

Chocolate brownie base with mini marshmallows, toasted walnuts, chocolate chips covered with chocolate ganache, truly a decadent taste.

Just like camping, when you want...smore! Buttery graham cracker base with chocolate brownie and marshmallow filling topped with more graham crackers, more chocolate chips and more marshmallows.

Chocolate base with a caramel center and more chocolate brownie on top with pecans, more caramel and chocolate drizzled on top.

Chocolate Cheesecake Brownie Bar

Decadent chocolate brownie base with creamy cheesecake on top with a drizzle of chocolate on top.

Gluten Free Blondie

Kind of a brownie with no cocoa powder, brown sugar and chocolate chips make this a delicious treat

Lunches

Our made from scratch in house bread start our sandwiches, your choice of sourdough or whole wheat, coming soon...Cranberry Walnut Bread, Roasted Garlic and Rosemary bread and a Seeded bread

CHICKEN SALAD SANDWICH

Our most popular sandwich, soft sourdough, a schmear of mayo, lettuce, tomato and chicken salad made with apples, raisins and a little red onion. Box includes side Caesar salad and tortilla chips.

TUNA SALAD SANDWICH

Albacore white tuna with crunchy celery, a little red onion, mayo and spices on sourdough bread with lettuce and tomato, add a side Caesar salad and tortilla chips for a full lunch.

EGG SALAD SANDWICH

Soft sourdough bread starts this sandwich, add lettuce, tomato and mayo if you want to our made from scratch egg salad, sorry there are no pickles in it. Box includes side Caesar salad and tortilla chips.

SLICED SMOKED TURKEY

Our own marinated and roasted turkey, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, a schmear of mayo on soft sourdough bread, add a side Caesar salad and tortilla chips to make it a box lunch.

The perfect sandwich starts with sourdough, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese, alfalfa sprouts and avocado, fresh in every bite, add a side Caesar salad and tortilla chips to make it a box lunch.

1/2 Garden OR Caesar W/ Roll

Caesar Salad has crispy romaine lettuce with toasty croutons, a sprinkle of parmesan cheese and a twist of lemon with our made from scratch dressing; Garden salad has crispy romaine, chopped cucumbers, tomatoes, mushrooms, sliced black olives and shredded swiss cheese with creamy parmesan dressing.

Crispy romaine lettuce tossed with buttery, toasty croutons, our own made-from-scratch Caesar dressing, a sprinkle of parmesan cheese and a twist of lemon.

Crispy romaine lettuce with chopped tomatoes, cucumbers, sliced mushrooms, sliced black olives and shredded cheese are tossed with our creamy parmesan dressing and served with a roll.

MATT'S TURKEY BACON

Let's start with our own turkey breast, marinated, roasted and hand sliced, add some bacon, lettuce, tomato, Monterey jack cheese on sourdough or whole wheat bread, a box lunch includes a side Caesar salad and tortilla chips.

Our own sourdough bread, grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, Monterey jack cheese, and luscious avocado make up this sandwich, make it a box with a side Caesar salad and tortilla chips.

Just like mom made, our meatloaf sandwich comes with red onion and spicy dijon mustard on our soft sourdough, add a Caesar salad and tortilla chips to make it a box lunch.

Crispy fresh romaine tossed with buttery toasted croutons, our own Caesar dressing, a sprinkle of parmesan cheese and wist of lemon with chopped turkey to add some protein.

California Salad

Mixed greens spring mix with mixed beans, feta cheese, toasted walnuts and California dressing (shallot vinaigrette).

Can't decide on what to taste, our salad sampler has a scoop of our chicken salad, tuna salad and egg salad with chopped cucumbers and chopped tomatoes.

Crispy romaine lettuce is the base for this salad with chopped turkey, chopped bacon, chopped tomato, hard boiled egg and blue cheese with an avocado garnish and Basil Vinaigrette, a toasty roll completes this salad.

Want a little bit of everything? Your choice of 2-- a smaller soup, a half Caesar or garden salad or half of chicken, tuna, egg, or BLT. Just the right size.

We make these every day, tasty little treat while you are waiting for your lunch!

Ground beef, spices, onions, peppers and tomato round out this tasty treat.

Our quiche choices change daily, usually a veggie and a meat choice with tossed garden salad and a toasty roll.

Add CHEESE, AVO, SPROUTS, TOMATO, OLIVES, WALNUTS

Need a little extra, just ask!

Add CHICKEN BREAST, TURKEY OR BACON

Our own grilled chicken breast , turkey breast or bacon chopped or sliced for your salad or sandwich.

1/2 Sandwich-Chicken Salad, Tuna, Egg

Need a small bite? Our half sandwich is just the ticket, our made from scratch chicken salad, tuna salad or egg salad with lettuce, tomato and mayo on our soft sourdough bread.

Betty's BLT Sandwich

Double the bacon of our BLT, crispy bacon with lettuce, tomato and mayo. Box includes side Caesar salad and tortilla chips.

New Theresa California

Our most popular salad starts with crispy romaine lettuce and is topped with mixed beans, feta cheese, candied walnuts, dried cranberries, avocado and Basil Vinaigrette, delicious in every bite.

Original Theresa California

Our original salad starts with crispy romaine lettuce and is topped with mixed beans, feta cheese, toasted walnuts, avocado and Basil Vinaigrette, yum.

Texas Brownies-jalapeno Cheese Squares

Deliciously spicy, cheesy square of eggs, cheese and jalapenos, need I say more?

Quiche Slice Or Strata

A slice of our delicious, creamy quiche is just the right size for a quick breakfast! Quiche has a bottom crust, Stratas have bread cubes for a different texture.

1/2 Turkey Caesar

Looking for a smaller meal, the half Caesar with chopped turkey, toasty croutons, a sprinkle of parmesan cheese and our own made from scratch dressing is what you need.

Summer 2020 Veggie wrap for those who like veggies, a spinach wrap with hummus, roasted eggplant, zucchini, red and yellow pepper, red onion, baby portobellas, spinach, lettuce, tomato, sprouts and seeds

Add Scoop of Chicken or Tuna Salad

Gluten Free

Our gluten free flour has rice flour, cornstarch, tapioca and a few other things in it to make the most moist, tasty gluten free goodies!

Gluten Free Cookies

Gluten free cookies have bittersweet chocolate, tart cherries, coconut and toasted walnuts. Vegan cookies are salted chocolate chip.

GF/Vegan Cut Out Cookies-each

Yep, we can make them gluten free or vegan if that's what you need!

Gluten Free Blondie

Kind of a brownie with no cocoa powder, brown sugar and chocolate chips make this a delicious treat

GF Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Gluten Free Cupcake

The choices change daily! Could be vanilla with strawberry filling or a yummy chocolate or even carrot!

Gluten Free Scone

Vegan

Vegan cupcakes, cookies and vegan mint brownies, no animal products used in our vegan goodies.

Vegan Cheesecake

If you like peanut butter, this tastes like a peanut butter cup with a chocolate crust and cashew nut filling.

Carrot is a fan favorite!

Cakes

Your choice of plain cheesecake with sour cream topping or add fruit topping.

6" Candy Corn Cake

8" Boston Cream Cake

8" Cheesecake-pumpkin, white choc raspberry, orange chocolate

8" Irish Trinity Cheesecake

It was a favorite at Meg O'Malleys, Guinness Stout, Bailey's Irish Cream and Irish Whiskey make up this deliciously decadent cheesecake. CALL AHEAD TO ORDER

8" Pineapple Upside Down Cake

Cake Roll Chocolate Peppermint

SEASONAL AND so delicious. Chocolate cake with either chocolate mint or vanilla peppermint filling rolled up and drizzled with chocolate.

Cheesecake NY Style 8" Round

Chocolate Peanut Butter cake roll

Coconut Cream Double Layer Cake

Similar to an Italian cream cake, it has coconut and walnuts covered with cream cheese, coconut and walnuts.

COCONUT CREAM CAKE Single

Similar to an Italian cream cake, it has coconut and walnuts covered with cream cheese, coconut and walnuts.

10" Irish Trinity Cheesecake

10" Boston cream pie (10" Cake)

Pinata cake 4 Colored Layers Filled

Cake Roll Pumpkin with cream cheese filling

8" Double Layer Hummingbird Cake

Mini Cheesecake With Cherries

Pumpkin Cheesecake Squares

Mini Pineapple Upside Down Cake

PUMPKIN ROLL WITH NUTS

Cake Scrap Cake

3 Layer 8" Chocolate Devotion

Chocolate cake with chocolate mousse and chocolate buttercream, drizzled with chocolate ganache, it is all about chocolate!

Cake Boxes Per Box

Cookie Monster Cake

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER! Two layers of moist chocolate chip cake with 2 layers of chocolate chip cookies in between, cookie butter buttercream fills and frosts the outside with chocolate chips, edible chocolate chip dough, more cookies on the outside.

Dinner To Go

Made from scratch dinners to feed 2-3 guests and change through out the week include Mom's Meatloaf; Baked Ziti; Shepherd's Pie; Eggplant Parmigiano, Curried Chicken; Sausage and Cheese lasagna, and Stuffed Peppers with either Beef or Vegetarian filling. Chicken Pot Pie and Beef Pot Pie feed 6.

Chicken Pot Pie

Top and bottom crust filled with chicken, peas, carrots, onions, celery, potatoes in a creamy sauce, just like my mom used to make, this pot pie feeds 6.

EGGPLANT PARMESAN

BAKED ZITI/ MEAT

Traditional ziti with meat sauce, cheese, more cheese and more sauce, feeds 2-3.

MOM'S MEATLOAF DINNER

Order your favorite flavor of quiche for an easy morning breakfast, broccoli and cheddar; sausage and pepper; five cheese; roasted red peppers and artichoke hearts; meat lovers, too many choices for us!

Beef Stroganoff

Curried Chicken

BAKERY/ DESSERTS

MINI FRUIT TARTS-mini cupcake size

Christmas Crack

CALL AHEAD TO SEE OUR SELECTION TODAY! A snack treat for the holidays, chocolate, marshmallows, caramel, chocolate chips, sea salt...a sweet and salty treat!

Large Cookie Tray

Cake Roll Pumpkin with cream cheese filling

Mini Golden Doughnut

Chocolate Dipped Strawberry Cupcake

CALL AHEAD TO SEE OUR SELECTION TODAY! Chocolate cupcake with strawberry filling topped with buttercream and dipped in chocolate with a chocolate dipped strawberry on top.

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER

Cutout Cookies 1 Dozen

12 of our cream cheese dough cut outs with sugar sprinkles.

Flooded Cookies

Mini Bundt Cakes

Mini Cookies 1 Dozen

Triple Heart Brownies-SEASONAL

SEASONAL -All kinds of chocolate in this brownie in the shape of a heart.

GF Bread Loaf Gluten Free

Frosted Decorated Cutout Cookies

French Macarons

Pinata cake 4 Colored Layers Filled

GF/Vegan 6" Torted

Peanut Butter Blossom

Whoopie Pies Chocolate With Marshmallow

Chocolate whoopie pies with a marshmallow buttercream filling

Apple Crumb Coffee Cake

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER THIS DELICIOUS BREAKFAST GOODIE.

Small Strawberry Rhubarb OR Blueberry Peach Pie

Mini versions of our popular pies!

Funfetti-candy Filled

This is such a sweet surprise, candy fills the inside of the funfetti cupcake!

Lemon Raspberry Cupcake

Our most popular wedding cake flavor turned into a cupcake, lemon cake with raspberry filling topped with lemon buttercream.

Pumpkin Doughnut

Graveyard Brownie-SEASONAL

CALL AHEAD FOR THIS SEASONAL TREAT.. bones and dirt and bloody glaze top this Halloween favorite.

Mini Whoopie Pie

Chocolate with vanilla buttercream and sometimes red velvet with cream cheese filling, depends of who is baking.

Gingerbread With Lemon Glaze

SEASONAL Light and fluffy Gingerbread cake with lemon glaze, perfect for the fall!

Key lime cupcake baked with key lime cheesecake with key lime filling and key lime frosting, don't worry, be happy!

Lemon Lavender Cookies

Vegan Cake Balls

Mini Cupcake Boxes Charged Per Box

Smash Cake For 1st Birthday

Chocolate Raspberry Tart

Beverages

Freshly brewed iced tea, Coffee or Coffee drinks including espresso, cold brew, cold brew coffee, coke products, coconut water

Shot Of Flavor Syrup

Macchiato (Any Flavor) 12 oz

Macchiato No Syrup 16oz.

Cappucino Drink Hot Or Cold 12 oz

Latte 16 OzHot Or Cold

Honest Juice Box Or Small Water

Macchiato W/ Syrup 16oz.

Lavender Lemonade

Silk Or Almond Milk

Hot Chocolate Bombs

Alternate Milk- Oat/Soy/Almond

Pies

Double crust, single crust, crumb, lattice all toppings for our pies, fresh fruit, custard, quality chocolate, fat Georgia pecans, toasty walnuts, pumpkins, Kentucky Bourbon are all part of our pie creations. WE USUALLY NEED 48 HOURS NOTICE, PLEASE CALL THE BAKERY 321-952-5256 FOR ADDITIONAL ASSISTANCE!

PIE-Apple Cranberry Pie

PIE-Apple Crisp Pie

PIE-Blueberry Pie

PIE-Chocolate Cream Pie

Pie-Peanut Butter

PIE-CRANBERRY WALNUT

PIE-HOOSIER-chocolate, bourbon, pecan

PIE-LEMON MERINGUE

PIE-PEACH BLUEBERRY

Pie-French Silk Pie

Pie - Triple Berry

Pie-CoconutCream

PIE-STRAWBERRY RHUBARD

Strawberries and tart rhubarb fill this crust, topped with a beautiful design.

PIE-Raspberry Pie

Tender crust filled with raspberry goodness, no top crust.

Add Gluten Free or Vegan to 10" Pie

ADD Gluten Free Or Vegan To Small Pie

Mini Apple Crisp

GF Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

10" Boston cream pie (10" Cake)

Small Pies-Apple, Cherry, Blueberry

Small Pies-Pecan, Hoosier, Lemon Meringue

Special Orders

1/2 Pumpkin Cake Roll

Your choice of plain cheesecake with sour cream topping or add fruit topping.

10" Irish Trinity Cheesecake

8" Irish Trinity Cheesecake

It was a favorite at Meg O'Malleys, Guinness Stout, Bailey's Irish Cream and Irish Whiskey make up this deliciously decadent cheesecake. CALL AHEAD TO ORDER

Cake Roll Chocolate Peppermint

SEASONAL AND so delicious. Chocolate cake with either chocolate mint or vanilla peppermint filling rolled up and drizzled with chocolate.

Small Pies-Apple, Cherry, Blueberry

Small Pies-Pecan, Hoosier, Lemon Meringue

Mini Pineapple Upside Down Cake

ASSORTED DANISH

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER THIS DELICIOUS BREAKFAST GOODIE. We offer apricot, raspberry or cheese, great for the holidays!

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER YOUR FAVORITE FLAVOR!

CHERRY SOUR CREAM COFFEE CAKE

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER...Moist sour cream cake with tart sweet cherries in the batter topped with a buttery crumb topping.

Coconut Cream Double Layer Cake

Similar to an Italian cream cake, it has coconut and walnuts covered with cream cheese, coconut and walnuts.

CLDMichele's favorite to make, pastry horns filled with pastry cream.

PUMPKIN ROLL WITH NUTS

Order your favorite flavor of quiche for an easy morning breakfast, broccoli and cheddar; sausage and pepper; five cheese; roasted red peppers and artichoke hearts; meat lovers, too many choices for us!

Cocoa Bombs (Bagged With A Little Cookie)

Cinnamon Rolls-small

We run out of these as quick as we get them out of the oven. Our buttery dough rolled out and covered with butter and cinnamon, rolled up and baked to perfection, add some cream cheese frosting and you are set to go!

Mini Cinnamon Rolls

Seasonal

Hot Chocolate Bombs

1/2 Pumpkin Cake Roll

6" Candy Corn Cake

Pumpkin Cookies

8" Irish Trinity Cheesecake

It was a favorite at Meg O'Malleys, Guinness Stout, Bailey's Irish Cream and Irish Whiskey make up this deliciously decadent cheesecake. CALL AHEAD TO ORDER

Pumpkin Cheesecake Squares

Cake Roll Chocolate Peppermint

SEASONAL AND so delicious. Chocolate cake with either chocolate mint or vanilla peppermint filling rolled up and drizzled with chocolate.

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER YOUR FAVORITE FLAVOR!

CHERRY SOUR CREAM COFFEE CAKE

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER...Moist sour cream cake with tart sweet cherries in the batter topped with a buttery crumb topping.

Red Velvet Irish Cream Brownie

Cocoa Bombs (Bagged With A Little Cookie)

Vendor

Swanky Brush Cards

Christmas Canvas

Bread

SOUR DOUGH BREAD

ASSORTED DANISH

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER THIS DELICIOUS BREAKFAST GOODIE. We offer apricot, raspberry or cheese, great for the holidays!

Cinnamon Sour Cream Coffee Cake

Cinnamon fills the middle of this sour cream coffee cake with more cinnamon crumbs and walnuts on top.

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER YOUR FAVORITE FLAVOR!

CHERRY SOUR CREAM COFFEE CAKE

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER...Moist sour cream cake with tart sweet cherries in the batter topped with a buttery crumb topping.

Golden Doughnut

Still a delicious treat, a very velvety cake batter baked, dipped in butter and rolled in cinnamon sugar.

Cinnamon Rolls-large

Gluten Free Scone

Breakfast

ASSORTED DANISH

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER THIS DELICIOUS BREAKFAST GOODIE. We offer apricot, raspberry or cheese, great for the holidays!

Cinnamon Sour Cream Coffee Cake

Cinnamon fills the middle of this sour cream coffee cake with more cinnamon crumbs and walnuts on top.

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER YOUR FAVORITE FLAVOR!

CHERRY SOUR CREAM COFFEE CAKE

CALL AHEAD TO ORDER...Moist sour cream cake with tart sweet cherries in the batter topped with a buttery crumb topping.

Golden Doughnut

Still a delicious treat, a very velvety cake batter baked, dipped in butter and rolled in cinnamon sugar.

Cinnamon Rolls-large

Order your favorite flavor of quiche for an easy morning breakfast, broccoli and cheddar; sausage and pepper; five cheese; roasted red peppers and artichoke hearts; meat lovers, too many choices for us!

Gluten Free Scone

Cinnamon Rolls-small

We run out of these as quick as we get them out of the oven. Our buttery dough rolled out and covered with butter and cinnamon, rolled up and baked to perfection, add some cream cheese frosting and you are set to go!

Bacon Cinnamon Roll

Gluten Free & Vegan

Your cart is empty.